|
Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
|
Chronic Illness, Vol. 3, No. 4,
253-264 (2007)
DOI: 10.1177/1742395307085333
© 2007 SAGE Publications
Between remission and cure: patients, practitioners and the transformation of leukaemia in the late twentieth century
Emm Barnes
Wellcome Unit for the History of Medicine, Faculty of Life Sciences, University of Manchester, Simon Building, Brunswick Street, Manchester M13 9PL, UK, emm.barnes{at}manchester.ac.uk
Objectives: During the course of the 1960s and 1970s, acute leukaemia in childhood ceased to be invariably fatal and was recategorized as curable. The meaning of cure in this case, however, was problematic, as it was impossible for physicians to be certain that cancer would not return. This paper uses historical methods to explore how remission was understood by families with children with acute leukaemia during the period in which the first cures were announced, roughly 1972—77.
Methods: These comprised documentary analysis of records of the Medical Research Council's leukaemia working parties, published papers and letters on treatments for childhood leukaemia, and interviews with eight UK paediatric oncologists practising in UK hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s.
Results: Two approaches to defining `cure' in leukaemia can be identified. The first relied on statistical assessment of survival rates. I argue that the concept of `indefinite remission' came to serve for researchers and clinicians as a proxy measure of cure. However, the concept of `indefinite remission' left many patients and their families quite uncertain as to whether a cure had really happened. A second approach to defining cure therefore developed. Faced with uncertainty, patients, parents and psychologists sought to develop alternative measures of success — including the notion of `psychological cure' — that brought forward the moment of cure and its relief.
Conclusions: Changing conceptualizations of leukaemia shaped and were shaped by negotiations over the meaning of `remission' and `cure'. On the one hand, the statistical definition of cure was not available for years. On the other hand, psychological cure could begin from the time of first remission, even if medical absolution was not available for years.
Key Words: Children • Cure • Framing • Leukaemia • Psychological cure • Remission
References
- Pinell P. The fight against cancer: France 1890—1940. London: Routledge, 2002.
- Lerner B. The breast cancer wars: hope, fear, and the pursuit of a cure in twentieth-century America. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
- MRC files FD 7/323, 7/325, and 7/33. National Archives, Kew.
- Rosenberg C. Framing disease: illness, society and history. In: Rosenberg C, Golden J, eds. Framing disease: studies in cultural history. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1992.
- Feudtner C. `Minds the dead have ravished': shell shock, history, and the ecology of disease-systems. History Sci 1993; 21: 377—420.
- D'Angio G., Beckwith JB, Breslow NE, et al. Wilms' tumor: an update. Cancer 1980; 45: 1791—8.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Löwy I. Between bench and bedside: science, healing, and interleukin-2 in a cancer ward. London: Harvard University Press, 1996.
- Keating P., Cambrosio A. From screening to clinical research: the cure of leukaemia and the early development of the Cooperative Oncology Groups, 1955—1966. Bull History Med 2002; 76: 299—334.[CrossRef]
- MRC file FD 7/314. National Archives, Kew.
- Papers of Wataru Sutow, series VI, folder 54. The McGovern Collection, Houston Academy of Medicine and Texas Medical Center Library.
- MRC files FD 10/218. National Archives, Kew.
- Burchenal J. Long-term survivors in acute leukemia and Burkitt's tumor. Cancer 1968; 21: 595—9.[CrossRef][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Laszlo J. The cure of childhood leukaemia: into the age of miracles. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1996.
- Christie D, Tansey E, eds. Wellcome witness to twentieth century medicine. Vol. 15: Leukaemia. London: The Wellcome Trust, 2003.
- MRC files FD 7/323, 7/325 and 7/330. National Archives, Kew.
- Acute leukaemia. Lancet 1965; 286: 938—9.[CrossRef]
- James K., Kay H. Some aspects of current therapy in acute leukaemia. Lancet 1967; 289: 206—9.[CrossRef]
- Long remissions in leukaemia. Lancet 1971; 297: 742—3.[CrossRef]
- Medicine: study of childhood leukaemia. The Times, 10 March 1973, p. 16.
- Parents' letters preserved in MRC files FD 9/789 and 9/1934, and Ministry of Health files MH 160/74 and 160/75.
- MRC Working Party on Leukaemia in Childhood. Duration of survival of children with acute leukaemia. BMJ 1971; 7—9.
- McCarthy M. Medical care of childhood leukaemia. Lancet 1975; 305: 1128—30.[CrossRef]
- McCarthy M. Social aspects of treatment in childhood leukaemia. Soc Sci Med 1975; 9: 263—9.[CrossRef][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Hardisty R. Medical care of childhood leukaemia. Lancet 1975; 305: 1235.
- Taylor G, ed. Pioneers in pediatric oncology. Houston: The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, 1990.
- Aur R., Simone J., Hustu H., Verzosa M. A comparative study of central nervous system irradiation and intensive chemotherapy early in remission of childhood acute lymphocytic leukemia. Cancer 1972; 29: 381—91.[CrossRef][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Radical treatment of acute leukaemia in childhood. Lancet 1972; 300: 910—11.[CrossRef]
- Spiers A. Cure as the aim in therapy for the acute leukaemias. Lancet 1972; 00: 473—5.
- Pinkel D. Nine years experience with `total therapy' of childhood acute lymphocytic leukemia. Pediatrics 1972; 50: 246—51.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- George S., Aur R., Mauer A., Simone J. A reappraisal of the results of stopping therapy in childhood leukemia. N Engl J Med 1979; 300: 269—73.[Abstract]
- Cancer 1975; 36: 267—304.[CrossRef]
- Bluebond-Langner M. The private worlds of dying children. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1978.
- Koocher G, O'Malley J, eds. The Damocles syndrome: psychosocial consequences of surviving childhood cancer. London: McGraw-Hill, 1981 (also lists other studies).
- Eiser C. Cancer in children. London: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2004.
- Johnson F., Miller M. Shannon: a book for parents of children with leukaemia. New York: Hawthorn Books, 1975.
- http://www.ohsu.edu/about/ohsufoundation/giveto_ doernbecher/ohsu_leaders.html (accessed November 2007).
- Lund D. Eric, New York: Dell Publishing Company, 1974.
- Sherman M. The leukemic child. Bethesda: Department of Health, Education and Welfare, 1976.
- Schweers E. Parents' handbook on leukemia. Providence: Rhode Island Hospital, 1975.
- Comaroff J., Maguire P. Ambiguity and the search for meaning: childhood leukaemia in the modern clinical context. Soc Sci Med 1981; 15B: 115—23.
- Eys J. The outlook for the child with cancer. J School Health 1977; 47: 165—9.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Eys J, ed. The truly cured child: the new challenge in pediatric cancer care. Baltimore: University Park Press, 1977.
- Eys J. The truly cured child: the realistic and necessary goal in pediatric oncology. In: Spinetta J, Deasy-Spinetta P, eds. Living with childhood cancer., London: CV Mosby, 1981: 30—40.
- Pinkel D. Current issues in the management of children with acute lymphocytic leukaemia. Postgrad Med J 1985; 61: 93—102.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Barnes E. Captain Chemo and Mr Wiggly: patient information for children with cancer in the late twentieth century. Soc History Med 2006; 19: 501—19.[CrossRef]
- Barnes E. Caring and curing: paediatric cancer services since 1960. Eur J Cancer Care 2005; 14: 373—80.[CrossRef]
- De Raeve L. Positive thinking and moral oppression in cancer care. Eur J Cancer Care 1997; 6: 249—56.[CrossRef]
- Bovey S. Exploding the cancer myths. The Guardian, 5 July 2005.
 CiteULike  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati What's this?
|
